Thus for Hegel, the concept is not ultimately the 12 categories of the understanding but thought thinking itself i. I realize the Hegel part is pretty unclear by itself, but the basic idea is that for Hegel, the list of categories is a stepping stone. If we look carefully, we will find problems with each of them for instance Kant's followers came up with different lists , and we'll find cases they don't manage.
As this process continues, we will get ever changing lists until we finally hit upon the perfect way to parse our reality, and that will for Hegel be the Absolute and the Concept.
To give one example usage, Auxier and Herstein discuss the two terms in their book on Whitehead, The Quantum of Explanation. They point out that Whitehead differentiates between the order of ideas and the logic of concepts. Whitehead titles one of his books Adventures of Ideas.
In it he lists seven large ideas that have ordered and shaped history. It could not have been called Adventures of Concepts. The distinction here places ideas at a broader level, and assigns them a historical character - think of the 'ideals' of a time - whereas concepts are finer grained and are what govern an individual's particular experience. They write for example that:. If you read Shaviro's book Without Criteria , on Kant and Whitehead, he is more apt to draw on Kant's distinction between ideas and concepts, by quoting Kant's assertion e.
In both these cases, loosely speaking, ideas are regulative and operate at a broader level of generality than concepts, which are operative and do the actual work of cognizing something i. But by no means are the two terms "settled and accepted" - its a matter of close reading on a case-by-case basis, keeping an eye on the inevitable debates that arise in the secondary literature What precisely does Kant mean by an "aesthetic idea" or Whitehead by a "logic of concepts" etc?
I have long pondered this question specifically in reference to mathematics. What makes the most sense to me is to consider that an "idea" refers to an approach to accomplishing something.
For example,once it occurred to someone that such notions as "half" and "third" etc. We can think of a number of possibilities to express some number of equally sized subdivisions; but the one we use is the ingenious idea of a "formal division," i. This is a very ingenious idea. The word "concept" seems best to refer to an image in the mind which could include a belief that has no basis in reality which is true of many concepts.
The answer to your second question is easy and complex, but also more significant than the first: "No. It is similar to asking a room full of philosophers what "philosophy" means.
Can there be a settled and accepted definition of philosophy? I'm not trying to trivialize here. I sincerely care about this issue, and try to do my best to respect it in each case. On the jovoto platform we often refer to ideas and concepts and we thought it would be useful to take a closer look at both to really see what the difference is. You can think of a concept as a ship and ideas as the crew. Neither are at their best without the other. You want your ship to have a purpose.
Is it carrying something? Where is it going? What route will it take? In the same way, ideas are what make a concept become reality, they are the crew that drive the concept forward. Individual crew members are of course valuable without a ship, they have skills that can be used elsewhere, just like some ideas can stand alone.
But on a ship is where a crew member works best and ideas are usually more powerful when they are used within a wider concept. A concept is generally more tightly defined than an idea. In comparison, ideas are often vague with less focus on a specific procedure and related details.
Normally, during the planning stage, a number of ideas are initially encouraged and drawn out. This leads to having the best ideas.
Idea is generally perceived as less academic or technical as compared to concept. For instance, concept is more likely associated with scholastic terms such as growth mindset, grit, models, and cause and effect as well as entrepreneurial ones like product concept and marketing concept. Ideas are more spontaneous as compared to concepts. There are instances when ideas just seem to come out of the blue such as when we have flashes of insight.
On the contrary, concepts are thought of for a certain time and the terms, procedures, and other details go through a process. Cite APA 7 Brown, g. Difference Between Idea and Concept. Difference Between Similar Terms and Objects.
MLA 8 Brown, gene. Name required. Email required. Please note: comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. Written by : gene Brown. For an example, let us concentrate on Sociology. In Sociology , there are various perspectives, theories and also concepts.
Concepts, in this sense, refer to the various interpretations of terms. For an example, Durkheim spoke of Organic and Mechanic solidarity. These are two concepts that are being studied when focusing on the transition from traditional societies to modern societies. Let us take a single concept for elaboration.
Mechanical solidarity suggests that the bond among people in traditional societies is created through homogeneity. It is the similarities that bind the people together. This highlights that the term Concept is used to describe a particular idea that is abstract in nature. In the day today conversation, we use the term concept as well.
0コメント